Immigration Appeals and Wrongful Denial Litigation

If the Board of Immigration Appeals has ruled against you, two things matter right now.

There are 30 days to appeal a Board decision to the federal court of appeals. That deadline cannot be extended for any reason, and asking the Board to reconsider does not pause it.

Filing an appeal does not stop a deportation. A separate request for an emergency stay has to be filed.

This page also covers a different kind of case: suing USCIS in federal court when it has wrongly denied a petition, such as an EB-1A.

Call (858) 224-2585Send an inquiry

Appeal or lawsuit? Two different paths

People often mix these up. They start in different places and go to different courts. If you are not sure which one fits your situation, call us and we will sort it out with you.

Immigration appealWrongful denial lawsuit
Starts withA loss in immigration court, such as a denied asylum claim or a removal orderA denial from USCIS, such as an EB-1A or other petition
Goes toThe Board of Immigration Appeals, then the federal court of appeals (the Ninth Circuit for cases decided in California)A federal district court, in a lawsuit against the agency
Deadline30 days at each stepThe sooner, the better
What the court decidesWhether the law was applied correctlyWhether the agency's decision was legally wrong or unreasonable on the record it had

Appealing an immigration court decision

An appeal from immigration court moves in two steps:

  1. From the immigration judge to the Board of Immigration Appeals. The appeal is due 30 days after the judge's decision.

  2. From the Board to the federal court of appeals. This is called a petition for review, and it is also due 30 days after the Board's decision.

What a federal appeals court can review

The court of appeals looks at whether the law was applied correctly. It does not weigh the evidence again or substitute its own judgment about whether someone deserved relief.

  • Asylum, withholding of removal, and protection under the Convention Against Torture can all be reviewed.

  • A criminal record limits what can be appealed, but it does not end the case. Legal and constitutional questions can still be raised.

  • Issues generally have to have been raised before the Board to be raised in the court of appeals. If you are still before the Board, that matters now.

Emergency stays of removal

A stay of removal is a court order that pauses a deportation while the appeal is decided. To get one, the request has to show both a strong case on appeal and specific, concrete harm to this person if they are removed. The general risk of being deported is not enough on its own.

In the Ninth Circuit, filing a timely stay motion triggers a temporary pause on removal while the court decides the motion. That is not true in most other circuits, which is one more reason to file quickly.

A stay is the strongest protection available during an appeal. It is not an absolute guarantee.

Wrongful denial litigation: suing USCIS over a denial

Sometimes USCIS denies a petition that should have been approved. It may have misread the evidence, applied the wrong standard, or ignored part of the record. In those cases, the denial can be challenged in federal district court in a lawsuit against the agency under the Administrative Procedure Act.

This is common right now with EB-1A extraordinary ability petitions, and it applies to other petitions as well, most of them decided against a set of criteria: EB-2 NIW, EB-5, O-1, H-1B, L-1, E-2, E-3, and family petitions.

What the court looks at

The court reviews the decision USCIS made, based on the record USCIS had in front of it. The question is whether the agency's decision was legally wrong or unreasonable, not whether the court would have decided the petition differently.

When a lawsuit succeeds, the court usually sets the denial aside and sends the petition back to USCIS to decide again. It does not order USCIS to approve it.

Lawsuit or AAO appeal?

USCIS denials can often also be appealed inside the agency, to the Administrative Appeals Office. An AAO appeal is not required before going to federal court.

Some decisions cannot be reviewed in court at all. We will tell you if yours is one of them before you spend anything.

What we need to evaluate your case

If you are appealing an immigration court decision:

  • The Board's decision, and the date on it

  • The immigration judge's decision

  • Whether the person is detained, and where

  • Whether a removal date has been set

If USCIS denied your petition:

  • The denial notice

  • The petition you filed and its supporting evidence

  • Any request for evidence you received, and your response

If a Board decision is involved, call rather than email. The 30 days started on the date of the decision.

Common questions about immigration appeals

For referring attorneys

If your firm handles removal defense but not federal court, send us Board denials the same week they come in, even before the client has decided anything. We would rather review ten and file two than hear about the eleventh after the 30 days have run.

We handle the petition for review and any stay motion. You keep everything else.

The same goes for USCIS denials: if a client's petition was denied and federal court is outside your practice, we take the lawsuit and you keep the client.

Refer a matter

If you have a Board decision, the clock is already running

Call today. Tell us the date on the decision and where the person is, and we will tell you honestly what can still be done.

Call (858) 224-2585Send an inquiry